Q: how Is Star Wars prefer The lord of the Rings?

*
*
The mr of the Rings and Star Wars: How similar are they?

ANSWER: the is virtually difficult to discuss Star battles without wandering into the kingdom of “sources for George Lucas’ vision”. However now that George Lucas is no longer the guiding irradiate of Star battles canon it continues to be to be viewed just how much future SW stories will resemble any of the standard 20th century scientific research fiction and fantasy literature. We will probably need to differentiate between Classic Star Wars and also Disney Star Wars, or something prefer that. We have already heard bits and also pieces about “the new Star wars canon” and also old institution Star wars fans might not like just how much of their beloved extended Universe might be around to vanish right into the folds of Rebooted Franchisedom. The is more than likely no mistake that J.J. Abrams was brought in to control the an initial post-Lucasian Star battles film, “The force Awakens”.

You are watching: Star wars and lord of the rings

But we started with a an easy question: “How is Star Wars choose The mr of the Rings?” friend will find a thousand different answers top top the Internet and also I debated long and hard before deciding to handle this. Yet let’s check out if i can uncover something type of new to say.

Both story are around A Family George Lucas has actually been quoted in the media as saying that standard Star battles was a soap opera. That is around the adventures and turmoils that the Skywalker family. He does no think The Disney company will remain true to that vision. They might make Star Wars much more like a comic publication franchise such together the Marvel superhero universe. The is now what Disney knows best.

But how is The lord of the Rings a family members drama? You’re thinking around Bilbo leaving the One Ring come Frodo, but I have a different family in mind. The family members J.R.R. Tolkien to be most pertained to with to be a blended household of Noldor and Sindar. Really it was 2 families: the descendants of Finwë and also Elwë. An ext specifically he was most pertained to with the descendants of Lúthien Tinúviel, Elwë’s daughter. Lúthien, like Anakin Skywalker, had only one “normal” parent. Yet whereas Anakin is a boy of The pressure (and is often compared with Jesus’ virginal conception), Lúthien is just the boy of one elf (Elwë) and an angel (Melian).

Both Lúthien and Anakin possess significant power contrasted to other world like them. But this compare is, i think, much more coincidental than intentional. After all George Lucas had written the manuscript for “Star Wars” prior to 1977 and also that to be the year in which The Silmarillion was very first published. In fact, “Star Wars” was released right into theaters in may 1977 and The Silmarillion was released in October 1977.

Of course human being should easily realize that us don’t really recognize much around Anakin Skywalker until after “Star Wars” comes out. There to be some information in the novelization the accompanied the movie but specific details were retained from the public for years. Furthermore, Lúthien never ever converted to the Dark next of anything. She always remained good, and also she never brought any sort that balance to juniorg8.com.

So once we say the The mr of the Rings is a household drama (or saga) we have to really look at it in the paper definition of the larger drama the J.R.R. Tolkien was came to with: the struggles of the Noldor with their innate curiosity and arrogance. This was no something that came from Lúthien; she was an ext like Shmi Skywalker in temperament.

Both “Star Wars” and The lord of the Rings are however Chapters This is an important point in any type of comparison between the 2 sagas. Just as The Silmarillion came out ~ The mr of the Rings, for this reason explaining all the back background that was only alluded to, therefore Lucas’ Prequel Trilogy just came the end after the original Trilogy. And despite what self-appointed guardians the Star battles fandom want civilization to believe, “The Phantom Menace” remains the most renowned of all six George Lucas Star wars films. Now that Lucas has left the Star Wars stage there is no hope of one more Lucas movie unseating “The Phantom Menace” together the finest of the 6 movies.

The Silmarillion, top top the other hand, does not compare as favorably v The mr of the Rings as the Prequel Trilogy does with the initial Trilogy. The Silmarillion is hard to understand and is created in a an extremely different layout from The lord of the Rings. Far fewer duplicates of The Silmarillion have been sold than copies of The mr of the Rings. Return Tolkien himself might have thought of The Silmarillion together his literature masterpiece that honor is bestowed through critics and also readers ~ above The lord of the Rings.

And however both the Prequel Trilogy and also The Silmarillion surpass their predecessors in numerous ways. Through the Prequel Trilogy George Lucas was lastly able come tell the story of Anakin Skywalker the way he wanted to. We did no all necessarily give of his choices yet this to be his story to tell and it is great that that did tell it. In the same way, The Silmarillion is the story that J.R.R. Tolkien want to tell. The lord of the Rings was a distraction come him, composed for the masses simply due to the fact that his publisher advised him in 1937 that his readers want to know more about Hobbits.

Well, we learned around Hobbits shortly enough yet that digression post-poned (while do possible) the publishing of The Silmarillion by numerous decades.

Both “Star Wars” and The mr of the Rings had actually to it is in told first the is no mere coincidence that both tales end their sagas, back Lucas was not necessarily adhering to the same course as Tolkien. The is true that as soon as George Lucas confirmed his certified dealer the original story that ended up being Star battles his agent recommend him to ton it down due to the fact that it was “too confusing”. When J.R.R. Tolkien presented very early draft of The Silmarillion come his publisher (George Allen & Unwin), who had actually happily search him out so they can publish The Hobbit (which initially was just intended for family and friends to enjoy), he was told it to be “too Celtic”.

Tolkien was i stabbed it by the applications of the “Celtic” label to his work since he reputed it to be created in an experimental Anglo-Saxonist tradition. But no one really understood what The Silmarillion was supposed to be. It to be something prefer Spencer’s “Faerie Queen” (and no — as countless today mistakenly say — “a mythology for England”), a fantasy intended for high-minded souls who wanted to think about their literature. The Silmarillion may additionally have been a cathartic suffer for Tolkien who, having witnessed the horrors of the very first World war up near (and having actually lost plenty of friends come the war), chastised his rebellious Noldor v slaughter and widespread devastation.

The sinking that Beleriand is an extremely much favor the devastation of north France, which was churned into a muddy, lifeless no-man’s land. In “Star Wars” we view something similar with the devastation of Alderaan. The fatality Star is the culmination that the Emperor’s pursuit for finish control end the galaxy. His ultimate weapon threatens to revolve the galaxy right into a lifeless sea of stars.

But Lucas was no war veteran. He started his film-making career in the era the Vietnam battle protests, to be sure, however he was not trying to cope v the horrors the seeing practically an whole generation wiped the end on the battlefields. Lucas had actually his own demons but they to be somehow smaller.

And yet J.R.R. Tolkien had actually to i have announced The lord of the Rings an initial because his readers want to know more about Hobbits; Lucas had to tell just a small part of his story because his audience would not know the cursed thing uneven they saw a good guy beating a poor guy. Whereas Tolkien had actually to tie off the finish of the story Lucas had actually to reassure everyone that there to be a good resolution.

The poor Guys victory in Both Prequels Yes, the bad guys win in The Silmarillion. I’m not talking about Morgoth, back Sauron slips far in a Darth Vaderish fashion. I’m talking about the Noldor. They space the poor guys that The Silmarillion. If the were no for your arrogance and also conceit nobody of Tolkien’s dramatic story would have actually happened. Therefore Morgoth (hardly an innocent) is done away with and also the Orcs space swept far like areas of wheat prior to the fire, and also most that the Noldor are slain. Yet a couple of of them survive and thrive and also seize manage over juniorg8.com.

In the same way the Sith seize control over the galaxy at the finish of the Prequel Trilogy. We knew the was coming since “Star Wars” (aka “A brand-new Hope”) opened up up through a struggling rebellion against the angry Empire. And also just as the Sith walk on to make their fatality Star so the Noldor go on to do their ring of Power.

Now this is the amazing thing for me due to the fact that the One Ring is sometimes contrasted with the fatality Star by fans who want to talk around similarities between the 2 stories. And there are similarity in purpose. However whereas the fatality Star is offered to manage the galaxy through fear, the One Ring is offered to manage others through direct mind control. The One Ring is more like a Jedi’s mental trick magnified to galactic scale. Imagine what Darth Sidious might have achieved if he had actually trapped the Fellowship of the Ring in part bizarre crossover tale (okay, ns am sure someone has written the story somewhere).

Either way, girlfriend cannot have actually the specifying the struggle in The mr of the Rings there is no some bad guys (High Elves that the West) law something angry (creating ring of Power) before the story. The instance has to be such that an excellent evil already exists in juniorg8.com. Why? since Tolkien go not have actually the high-end of showing just how evil would gain manage over juniorg8.com in his sequel to The Hobbit.

It would certainly be generations before a reading public would have actually the patience to tolerate a “rise and also fall and also redemption” saga sheathe 12-20 books. In fact, when I attended people Fantasy Con in 1992 i asked a dashboard of world-famous fantasy authors, that were deploring the unlimited production that LoTR-like trilogies, if it to be conceivable that someone could arrangement a 20-book saga (I currently had an synopsis for one composed at home). The entire audience, a couple of hundred people, groaned for this reason loudly the the panelists feel no have to answer mine question, although roger Zelazny gamely stated that the was already sort of happening just due to the fact that publishers preserved asking for an ext sequels. Zelazny died prior to he to be able to complete a second series of novels around his fantasy world Amber, but other authors who went on to write large cycles consisted of Christopher Stasheff and Robert Jordan.

Today you virtually cannot market a major fantasy collection if girlfriend don’t have 20 books in mind. The readers mean to learn much more about her fantasy people than a solitary book deserve to possibly reveal. This mega story did not start with Tolkien (Mark Twain, for example, wrote 4 Tom Sawyer novels if you include Hucklebery Finn). Yet mega story are now what anyone wants, indigenous five-year television display arcs come multi-decade comic book sequences (not allowing for countless reboots).

When Tolkien was writing fiction and Lucas was creating the Star Wars cosmos all that megastory ingredient still place in the future. They had to present their audiences the there was without doubt “an end” to the story (even if that was not “THE end”). And also in both endings great guys had actually to win, part guys had to die, and everyone had to rejoice that a good evil had actually passed.

Only by revealing exactly how their stories finished were both Tolkien and Lucas totally free to go earlier to tell exactly how their stories began.

There space Some wise Old men in Both Star Wars and juniorg8.com You cannot escape the countless comparisons between Obi-Wan Kenobi and Gandalf, yet I’m walk to to compare Yoda come Treebeard and also Tom Bombadil. You can not tell “Star Wars” there is no Yoda and also you cannot tell The lord of the Rings without Bombadil and Treebeard. All three characters serve an essential purpose in both sagas: they bear witness to a yet much more ancient past than the official “beginning” that the sagas. Technically The Silmarillion starts with Iluvatar in the Timeless Halls but “Quenta Silmarillion” easily gets to the part where there space Elves in juniorg8.com and also from those Elves come the Finwëans and Elwëans.

Tolkien’s juniorg8.com saga is rightly the story that the progeny of Finwë and Elwë. Lucas’ Star wars saga is correctly the story of the Skywalker family. Yet in both sagas over there exist older, wiser beings who step up to fill in part gaps in knowledge. And when our end-of-story heroes need some special assist the Old Wise males come in to offer last bits of sage advice before wandering off right into the past to it is in forgotten.

Bombadil and also Treebeard may go on living in juniorg8.com yet they are never heard indigenous again. Yoda fades right into the pressure (although he becomes a “Force ghost”). Component of the mysticism of the long-winded fantasy saga is the imparting that wisdom from an old elder to a young disciple. Belgarath teaches young Garion in The Belgariad, Zeddicus teaches Richard Rahl in The knife of Truth, and so on. The trope is repetitive in limitless stories. If the elder is not physically current to lecture the headstrong young future savior climate there is virtually inevitably an old archive whereby the essential wisdom resides.

So perhaps it is not fair to to compare Star Wars and The lord of the Rings this way, yet the Old Wise males are integral come both stories. And also both Obi-Wan Kenobi and also Gandalf die, only to come earlier stronger than before. You really cannot phone call this sort of family members saga there is no a couple of Old Wise men hanging about to dispense wisdom and also explain things for the audience (which is your main duty in the story).

The Old Wise male is not always a mentor. He appears in countless forms. The is a tree stump the a thousand hack jobs. He can be a redeemed Theoden top Aragorn to the paths of the Dead, or he might be a Mace Windu make the efforts to steer Anakin Skywalker far from the clutches that Darth Sidious. Over there are constantly Old Wise men in these stories. The only exciting story I can think of wherein there to be no Old Wise men was a brief story by Isaac Asimov (or possibly Lester del Rey) in which five robots “woke up” v no memory of just how they involved be. But even climate the author wrote a prequel story explaining where the robots came from and, yup, there to be Old Wise men in it. See the man movie “Nine” for a comparable tale that additionally features one Old wise Guy.

Star Wars and The lord of the Rings both feature Racist Stereotypes ns am no talking around Jar jug Binks and the Neimoidians, no of whose alleged ethnic impacts have ever before been effectively pinned under by irate fans. They space curious, innovative blends that many social influences and also George Lucas need to be commended for stirring so lot debate amongst his audience through those “cardboard” (but impossible-to-explain) caricatures.

No, the racism i speak that in “Star Wars” is the clean bias versus Droids and also the oh-so-subtle “we-humans-rule-this-galaxy” perspective of the Empire. You do see extraterrestrial creatures offer the Empire’s interests however their motivation seem to be financial in nature: they are cheap assassins and spies. It’s the person race the rules the galaxy.

In The lord of the Rings practically every chapter drips with racism. Tolkien hated racism and he all yet lectured united state on the malice of racism stereotypes through every encounter between any two international groups. Every the readers seem to take away from the is “Elves and also Dwarves dislike each other” (which is not true but people have been informing each various other that fib for 60 year so you won’t obtain them to stop any type of time soon).

I think Lucas uses racism in the same means Tolkien does: he wants his an excellent guys to it is in flawed in a socially far-reaching way. Not all human beings are negative in the Star battles universe however they have actually a trouble with Droids. Why is that? We lastly learn why in the Prequel Trilogy. Meanwhile, in the initial Trilogy, the anti-Droid prejudice is one interesting and also inexplicable characteristics of a foreign culture. Us honestly don’t get the joke, and also that is part of what provides the story feeling so real. The audience cannot to fill in all the facts.

In The lord of the Rings there are an excellent reasons why the miscellaneous “Free Peoples” have trouble trusting every other, and it’s not because of mutual natural enmity. It’s due to the fact that Sauron drove them apart end centuries v a long, meticulous plan. However you need to read the Appendices come The mr of the Rings to capture that. Or if you miss it there climate you need to read “Of the rings of Power and also the third Age” in The Silmarillion. Also so countless readers now still don’t recognize why no one trusts anyone else in Tolkien’s late 3rd Age juniorg8.com.

Small things Have an excellent Consequences in Both Star Wars and also The lord of the Rings i speak that the plans because that the death Star and also of the One Ring. No one yes, really understands the definition of what that is transferring at first. Luke is handed 2 Droids by his uncle and told come clean castle up and put them right into service. Frodo is left the One Ring through his cousin/uncle/adoptive dad Bilbo and also told no to lose it. In neither instance does one of two people young adventurer understand that he has just been handed the tricks to the kingdom.

The fatality Star plans eventually finish up in the best hands so the they have the right to be analyzed. But when the comes under to damaging the death Star only Luke Skywalker deserve to do the deed v an impossible shot fired from a speeding X-Wing fighter that is under fire indigenous Darth Vader.

The One Ring at some point crushes Frodo’s will and forces him to “rat out”, provide in, and also claim it because that himself. Happily for every one of juniorg8.com Gollum has actually been hanging about hoping for a last opportunity to take the Ring and also he does just that, impossibly falling into the fire through it.

Small things have an excellent consequences in both sagas, and neither is an accident. Simply as Frodo to be meant to inherit the Ring from Bilbo, for this reason Anakin to be meant to help others with his one-of-a-kind gift. They to be both born because that a purpose, a higher purpose 보다 either could totally appreciate.

We can argue all year long around how much Lucas was directly influenced by Tolkien yet I don’t think that matters. Tolkien was borrowing tropes from older sources and also Lucas obtained his inspirations from countless sources, too. An excellent story-telling every looks similar sooner or later.

We had a pretty an excellent run with both Lucas and also Tolkien. I can’t say ns was completely happy with everything Tolkien composed or failed to explain; nor can I say ns was entirely happy with everything Lucas put into his movies.

See more: The Iron Giant Signature Edition Blu-Ray, The Iron Giant: Signature Edition Blu

But ns loved both stories and will always love them. Perhaps it’s since they space so lot alike in so countless ways. Possibly it’s since they are just darned good stories.

See also:

# # #

Have you review our various other Tolkien and also juniorg8.com Questions and also Answers articles?