The reviewers uncovered that both exercise and arthroscopic surgical procedure had actually a little effect on reducing knee pain, yet that the advantage from the surgical procedure disshowed up after 6 months.

You are watching: Meniscus removal long term effects


The reviewers discovered that both exercise and arthroscopic surgical procedure had a little impact on reducing knee pain, however that the advantage from the surgical treatment disappeared after six months.

Each year, an approximated 700,000arthroscopic surgeries are done on the knees of middle-aged and also older Americans to relieve chronic knee pain resulted in by osteoarthritis or a torn meniscus, the cartilage that cushions the knee bone and protects it from wear and also tear.

The proof for such surgical treatment has actually always been weak — only one clinical trial has actually reported that it benefits patients — yet many surgeons proceed to perdevelop the procedure.

Arthroscopic knee surgical treatment is considered minor surgical treatment, yet it is not without threats, consisting of infections and blood clots.

On Tuesday, a team of Danish and also Swedish researchers released a significant new systematic testimonial of nine formerly publimelted clinical trials that compared arthroscopic knee surgery to either exercise treatment or “placebo surgery” (faked surgical procedure in which the part of the procedure thneed to be therapeutically important is not done). The researches associated a full of 1,270 participants aged 49 to 62.

Post proceeds after advertisement

The reviewers found that both exercise and also arthroscopic surgical treatment had a little effect on reducing knee pain, yet that the benefit from the surgical procedure disappeared after 6 months.

The pain-relieving advantage that the patients received from arthroscopic surgery for a few months was comparable to taking an over-the-counter pain medicine and considerably much less than the result checked out from exercise treatment for knee osteoarthritis, the reviewers point out.

As for renovations in physical function, no difference was uncovered between the therapy teams.

Not without risk

The testimonial did find that arthroscopic knee surgery was associated through considerable and also significant health and wellness dangers, consisting of an raised danger of infection, blood clots in the legs and also lungs, and also death.

Of those dangers, occurring a blood clot in the legs was the many widespread — 4.13 events per 1,000 measures. The risk of fatality was slightly less than 1 per 1,000 actions.

The reviewers also suggest out that arthroscopy is connected with a particular permanent risk: an boosted likelihood of emerging osteoarthritis.

“Patients with previous knee surgical procedure undergo total knee arthroplasty at a substantially younger age than carry out patients without previous knee surgery,” they note.

At a tipping point

All these findings taken together “do not support the exercise of arthroscopic surgical procedure for middle-aged or older patients via knee pain via or without indications of osteoarthritis,” the reviewers conclude.

Degenerative meniscal tears (ones resulted in by years of wear and tear rather than by a single injury) and various other structural abnormalities that regularly display up on diagnostic knee images are simply as most likely to show up in the knees of middle-aged and also older human being who have actually no knee pain as those who perform, they include.

Article continues after advertisement

Hence, a patient’s knee pain may have nothing to do through the degenerative meniscal tear, and repairing that tear will certainly execute nopoint to relieve the patient’s symptoms.

“We may be close to a tipping allude where the weight of proof versus arthroscopic knee surgical treatment for pain is sufficient to get rid of involves about the top quality of the researches, confirmation predisposition, and vested interests,” writes Dr. Andy Carr, an orthopedic surgeon and professor of orthopedics at Oxford University in the UK, in an editorial that acproviders the study. “When that point is got to, we must anticipate a swift reversal of establiburned exercise.”

The testimonial was publimelted in the BMJ (formerly recognized as the British Medical Journal), wright here it can be downloaded and also review in full.

See more: Paypal Something Went Wrong On Our End, Paypal: Sorry, Something Went Wrong On Our End


Susan Perry

Susan Perry writes 2nd Opinion for MinnMessage, extending customer wellness. She has actually created numerous health-related publications, and her short articles have appeared in a wide array of publications.