Book VII that The Republic

The Allegory of the Cave

In Chinese: 柏拉圖:理想國 卷7:洞穴寓言 (translated through Liu Yu)

Here"s a little story indigenous Plato"s mostfamous book, The Republic.Socrates is talk to a young follower of his called Glaucon, and istelling him this fable to illustrate what it"s like to be a philosopher-- a lover that wisdom: most people, including ourselves, live in aworld of loved one ignorance. Us are also comfortable v thatignorance, since it is all we know. As soon as we first start facingtruth, the procedure may be frightening, and many people run ago totheir old lives. Yet if you proceed to seek truth, friend willeventually have the ability to handle that better. In fact, friend wantmore! It"s true that many people roughly you now may think you areweird or even a risk to society, but you don"t care. Onceyou"ve taste the truth, girlfriend won"t ever before want to go back to beingignorant!
– C. George Boeree


and now, i said, permit me display in a figure how farour nature isenlightenedor unenlightened: --Behold! people living in a underground den,whichhas a mouth open up towards the light and reaching all follow me the den; herethey have been from your childhood, and have your legs and neckschainedso that they cannot move, and can just see before them, being preventedby the chain from turning round your heads. Above and behind castle afireis blazing in ~ a distance, and also between the fire and also the detainees thereis a increased way; and also you will certainly see, if you look, a low wall surface built alongthe way, choose the display which marionette players have in prior ofthem,over i beg your pardon they display the puppets.

You are watching: Better to be the poor servant of a poor master

ns see.


And do you see, i said, guys passing follow me the wall surface carrying allsortsof vessels, and also statues and also figures of animals made that wood and stoneandvarious materials, which appear over the wall? few of them aretalking,others silent.

You have presented me a weird image, and also they space strange prisoners.

Like ourselves, i replied; and also they see just their own shadows, ortheshadows that one another, i m sorry the fire throws on the opposite wall surface ofthecave?

True, the said; how might they check out anything but the shadows iftheywere never enabled to relocate their heads?

And that the objects which space being carried in like manner lock wouldonly view the shadows?

Yes, that said.

And if they were able come converse with one another, would they notsupposethat they to be naming what was actually prior to them?

Very true.

And suppose additional that the prison had actually an echo which came from theother side, would certainly they no be sure to fancy when one of the passers-byspoke the the voice which castle heard came from the passing shadow?

No question, the replied.

To them, i said, the fact would be literally nothing however theshadowsof the images.

That is certain.

And currently look again, and see what will normally follow if theprisonersare released and also disabused of your error. At first, when any type of of themisliberated and compelled all of sudden to stand up and turn his neck roundandwalk and look towards the light, that will suffer sharp pains; the glarewill distress him, and also he will certainly be unable to check out the realities the whichin his previous state he had seen the shadows; and also then develop some onesaying come him, that what that saw before was an illusion, but that now,whenhe is draw close nearer come being and also his eye is turned in the direction of morerealexistence, he has actually a clearer vision, -what will be his reply? and youmayfurther imagine the his instructor is pointing come the objects as theypass and also requiring that to name them, -- will certainly he not be perplexed? Willhenot an elaborate that the shadows i beg your pardon he previously saw space truer than theobjectswhich space now shown to him?

Far truer.

And if that is compelled come look right at the light, will he nothavea pain in his eye which will certainly make him revolve away come take and take intheobjects the vision i beg your pardon he have the right to see, and also which that will conceive to it is in inreality clearer than the things which are currently being shown to him?

True, the said.

And suppose when more, the he is reluctantly dragged increase a steep andrugged ascent, and also held fast until he"s forced into the visibility ofthesun himself, is he not likely to it is in pained and irritated? once heapproachesthe irradiate his eyes will certainly be dazzled, and also he will not have the ability to seeanythingat all of what room now referred to as realities.

Not every in a moment, he said.

He will call for to flourish accustomed come the sight of the top world.And very first he will watch the shadows best, next the reflect of males andother objects in the water, and also then the objects themselves; then hewillgaze upon the irradiate of the moon and the stars and the spangled heaven;and that will see the sky and the stars by night better than the sunlight orthelight that the sun by day?


Last of every he will be able to see the sun, and also not mere reflections ofhim in the water, yet he will check out him in his own proper place, and also notin another; and he will contemplate him as he is.


He will then continue to argue the this is the who offers the seasonandthe years, and also is the guardian the all that is in the clearly shows world, andin a certain method the reason of all points which he and also his fellows havebeen accustomed to behold?

Clearly, he said, the would first see the sun and also then reasonabouthim.

And as soon as he remembered his old habitation, and also the wisdom of the denand his fellow-prisoners, execute you not mean that he would certainly felicitatehimselfon the change, and also pity them?

Certainly, he would.

And if they to be in the habit that conferring honours among themselveson those who were quickest to observe the happen shadows and to remarkwhich of them walk before, and also which followed after, and which weretogether;and that were thus best may be to draw conclusions as to the future,do girlfriend think the he would care for together honours and also glories, or envythepossessors the them? would certainly he not say with Homer,

Better to it is in the negative servant of apoor master, and also to endure anything,rather than think together they do and live after their manner?

Yes, that said, ns think that he would rather suffer anything thanentertainthese false notions and live in this miserable manner.

Imagine when more, i said, such a one coming unexpectedly out that thesunto be replaced in his old situation; would certainly he not be specific to havehiseyes full of darkness?

To it is in sure, the said.

And if there were a contest, and also he had actually to contend in measuring theshadows v the prisoners who had never moved out the the den, whilehissight was still weak, and also before his eyes had end up being steady (and thetimewhich would be necessary to get this new habit that sight might be veryconsiderable) would he no be ridiculous? males would say of him that uphe went and also down he come without his eyes; and that it was better notevento think that ascending; and also if any type of one make the efforts to loose another and also leadhimup come the light, allow them only capture the offender, and they would certainly puthimto death.

No question, that said.

See more: Difference Between Shampoo And Conditioner Vs Shampoo, What Order To Use Them While Bathing

This whole allegory, i said, you may now append, to ~ Glaucon, totheprevious argument; the prison-house is the human being of sight, the light ofthe fire is the sun, and also you will certainly not misapprehend me if girlfriend interpretthe trip upwards to it is in the climb of the soul into the intellectualworld follow to my bad belief, which, at your desire, i haveexpressedwhether correctly or wrongly God knows. But, whether true or false, myopinionis the in the civilization of understanding the idea of good appears critical of all,and is seen only with one effort; and, when seen, is additionally inferred to bethe universal author of all things beautiful and also right, parent of lightand that the lord of irradiate in this clearly shows world, and the immediatesourceof reason and also truth in the intellectual; and also that this is the poweruponwhich he that would action rationally, one of two people in publicly or exclusive lifemusthave his eye fixed.